top of page

Human Error: The Root Cause of Recent Cyber Security Issues in Australia

In recent years, Australia has faced a series of high-profile cyber security breaches that have compromised the personal data of millions of citizens. Experts argue that human error is a significant contributing factor in these incidents, underscoring the need for improved cybersecurity measures and heightened awareness. This article delves into the role of human error in these breaches, examines the factors that contribute to such errors, and explores the impact on Australian businesses. It also discusses preventative measures, lessons learned, and how Australia compares to global cybersecurity practices.

Key Takeaways

  • Human error is a major factor in recent cyber security breaches in Australia, including high-profile cases like Optus and Medibank.

  • Lack of training and awareness, complexity of security systems, and inadequate policies contribute to human error in cybersecurity.

  • The financial, reputational, and operational impacts of these breaches on Australian businesses are significant and far-reaching.

  • Preventative measures such as regular cybersecurity training, robust policies, and advanced security technologies can mitigate human error.

  • Lessons from recent incidents highlight the importance of continuous improvement, government regulations, and adopting global best practices to enhance cybersecurity.

The Role of Human Error in Recent Cyber Security Breaches in Australia

Case Study: Optus Data Breach

The Optus data breach, which compromised the personal information of eight million Australians, has been a significant case highlighting the role of human error. Former Australian Federal Police officer and cyber security expert Nigel Phair stated that human error was a very likely contributing factor. Despite Optus's strong controls around firewalls and intrusion detection, a weakness, likely human in nature, was exploited by cybercriminals.

Case Study: Medibank Data Breach

Similarly, the Medibank data breach underscores the critical impact of human error in cybersecurity. One of the world's top cybersecurity experts noted that human error almost certainly played a decisive role in this breach. The incident has led to a reevaluation of security protocols and the importance of addressing human vulnerabilities in cybersecurity strategies.

Expert Opinions on Human Error

Experts widely agree that human error is a significant factor in cybersecurity breaches. According to the 2022 Global Risks Report by the World Economic Forum, 95% of cybersecurity threats were in some way caused by human error. Additionally, the 2022 Data Breach Investigations Report (DBIR) found that 82% of breaches involved the human element, including social attacks, errors, and misuse.

Factors Contributing to Human Error in Cyber Security

Lack of Training and Awareness

Human error has a well-documented history of causing data breaches. Sometimes personnel may take cybersecurity requirements too lightly, leading to dramatic consequences for the organizations they work for. Careless or uninformed staff, for example, are the second most likely cause of a serious security breach, second only to malware.

Complexity of Security Systems

The breakdown of cyber incidents was ransomware – 29%, compromised or stolen credentials (method unknown) – 27%, phishing (compromised credentials) – 23%, brute-force attack (compromised credentials) – 9%, hacking – 8%, malware – 4%. The top causes of human error breaches were:

  • Personal information sent to wrong recipient (email) – 42%

  • Unauthorised disclosure (unintended release or publication) – 33%

  • Failure to use BCC when sending email – 6%

Inadequate Policies and Procedures

Former Australian Federal Police officer and cyber security expert Nigel Phair said human error was a very likely contributing factor in the massive data breach. "Organisations like Optus and many others of that ilk have really good controls around firewalls and identification of intrusions and that type of thing," Mr Phair said. "There's been a weakness somewhere and invariably that weakness, from what we've seen normally, is from a human."

Impact of Human Error on Australian Businesses

Human error within a business can have many undesirable effects. Human error almost certainly played a decisive role in the Medibank, Optus, and multitude of other data breaches plaguing Australian companies. This section explores the various impacts of human error on businesses in Australia.

Preventative Measures to Mitigate Human Error

Regular Cybersecurity Training

Regular cybersecurity training is essential to keep employees aware of the latest threats and best practices. Training should be conducted quarterly to ensure that all staff members are up-to-date with the latest security protocols. Key areas to focus on include:

  • Phishing and social engineering attacks

  • Safe internet and email usage

  • Password management

  • Recognizing and reporting suspicious activities

Implementation of Robust Policies

Implementing robust cybersecurity policies can significantly reduce the risk of human error. These policies should be clear, comprehensive, and regularly updated to reflect the evolving threat landscape. Important policies to consider include:

  1. Data protection and privacy policies

  2. Incident response plans

  3. Access control policies

  4. Regular audits and compliance checks

Use of Advanced Security Technologies

Advanced security technologies can help mitigate the risks associated with human error. Automated solutions, such as machine identity management and system monitoring tools, can provide full visibility and control over security systems. Key technologies include:

  • Automated machine identity management

  • Real-time system monitoring

  • AI and RPA for threat detection

  • Encryption and data loss prevention tools

Lessons Learned from Recent Cyber Security Incidents

Importance of Continuous Improvement

The series of high-profile cyber attacks over the past year have shaken confidence in Australia's cyber resilience, highlighting the need to reassess security strategies across all sectors. However, they have also provided important lessons for improvement.

Role of Government and Regulations

By learning from these events and taking a preemptive, intelligence-led approach, Australia has a chance to emerge stronger. Now is the time for decisive action that constructs a robust security architecture for the country -- one that can withstand the cyber challenges of tomorrow.

Future Directions for Cyber Security in Australia

Businesses must adopt a multi-layered defense strategy, including regular data backups, robust endpoint protection, and employee awareness training. The findings validate fears from executives around the world that human error will be the cause of their next cybersecurity breaches.

Key Takeaways

  • Regular reassessment of security strategies is crucial.

  • Government regulations play a pivotal role in shaping cyber resilience.

  • Multi-layered defense strategies are essential for future security.

  • Continuous employee training can mitigate human error.

Comparative Analysis: Australia vs. Global Cyber Security Practices

Australia's Cyber Readiness

Australia's cyber readiness has been a topic of concern. Several factors have been cited as contributing to Australia's relative cyber unreadiness compared with other countries. Moving forward, Australia must reevaluate the outdated focus on data sovereignty, recognizing the borderless nature of the cyber threat landscape. A comprehensive, nationwide cybersecurity strategy that embraces innovation is critical. Taking inspiration from her allies in the U.S., Australia must mandate minimum security standards for companies and critical infrastructure, regularly assess compliance, and strictly enforce consequences for breaches.

Global Best Practices

Globally, countries have adopted various best practices to enhance their cybersecurity posture. These include:

  • Mandating minimum security standards for companies and critical infrastructure.

  • Regularly assessing compliance and enforcing consequences for breaches.

  • Significantly boosting cybersecurity budgets to address workforce gaps.

  • Equipping security teams with advanced tools to defend against sophisticated cybercriminals.

  • Adopting cyber threat intelligence and attack surface management solutions to preemptively hunt down threats.

Recommendations for Improvement

To improve its cybersecurity stance, Australia should consider the following recommendations:

  1. Boost cybersecurity budgets to address workforce gaps and equip security teams with necessary tools.

  2. Mandate minimum security standards for companies and critical infrastructure.

  3. Regularly assess compliance and strictly enforce consequences for breaches.

  4. Adopt cyber threat intelligence and attack surface management solutions.

  5. Foster the development of cybersecurity skills and talent to meet growing demand.

The Human Element in Cyber Security: A Double-Edged Sword

Human error and malicious actions are two sides of the same coin in cybersecurity. While human error often stems from a lack of awareness or simple mistakes, malicious actions are intentional and aimed at causing harm. Both can lead to significant security breaches.

Psychological factors play a crucial role in cybersecurity. Stress, fatigue, and overconfidence can lead to mistakes that compromise security. On the other hand, malicious insiders may be driven by factors such as dissatisfaction or financial gain.

  • Case Study 1: An employee at a financial institution intentionally leaked sensitive customer data due to job dissatisfaction.

  • Case Study 2: A healthcare worker accidentally exposed patient records by falling for a phishing scam.


The recent spate of cyber security breaches in Australia, including high-profile incidents involving companies like Optus and Medibank, underscores the critical role of human error in these events. Despite robust technological defenses such as firewalls and intrusion detection systems, the human element remains a significant vulnerability. As highlighted by experts like former AFP officer Nigel Phair, and supported by global reports, human error is a predominant factor in the majority of cyber threats. This reality calls for a reassessment of current security strategies, emphasizing the need for regular cybersecurity training and a more cohesive policy framework. The lessons learned from these breaches provide a valuable opportunity for improvement, urging both public and private sectors to bolster their defenses against the ever-evolving landscape of cyber threats.

Frequently Asked Questions

What role does human error play in cyber security breaches?

Human error is a significant factor in cyber security breaches. Experts estimate that a large percentage of breaches involve human mistakes, such as misconfigurations, falling for phishing scams, and inadequate security practices.

Can you provide examples of recent cyber security breaches in Australia caused by human error?

Yes, notable examples include the Optus and Medibank data breaches. In these cases, human error was identified as a likely contributing factor, although some organizations have disputed this claim.

What are some common factors that contribute to human error in cyber security?

Common factors include lack of training and awareness, the complexity of security systems, and inadequate policies and procedures. These issues can lead to mistakes that compromise security.

How does human error impact Australian businesses?

Human error can have severe impacts on businesses, including financial losses, reputational damage, and operational disruptions. These consequences highlight the importance of addressing human error in cyber security strategies.

What measures can be taken to mitigate human error in cyber security?

Measures to mitigate human error include regular cybersecurity training for employees, implementing robust policies and procedures, and using advanced security technologies to detect and prevent mistakes.

How does Australia's cyber security readiness compare to other countries?

Australia has faced criticism for its cyber security readiness, with experts noting that the country lags behind others in terms of cohesive cybersecurity policies and practices. Continuous improvement and learning from global best practices are essential for enhancing Australia's cyber security posture.

0 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page